I fear that in listing best television shows of 2012, I will, like those who bestow Emmys, duplicate last year’s list, which included Breaking Bad, Mad Men, Boardwalk Empire, The Killing, Justified, The Hour, Downton Abbey, Treme, Modern Family, 30 Rock, Louie, and The Daily Show with Jon Stewart.
I’m still watching every single one of these superb series. Some were better than ever this season (Breaking Bad, Louie), others less great (Downton & Treme) or downright bad (The Killing). But overall, the shows on this list illustrate why so many of us believe that we are, indeed, living through the real Golden Age of television, which continues to generate an amazing number of superior viewing experiences that are mapping out an incredible new artform, somewhere between the movie and the novel.

I have little to add to the tonnage of online buzz about the aforementioned greatest shows, except to second the nomination by a number of film critics who chose to include Breaking Bad on their list of best films of the year. This show is dark, powerful, emotionally gripping, and utterly terrifying, and not just because its subject matter is the violent world of the meth business. No, it’s because of Walter White, whose soul has been bared in a relentless transformation from victim to villain. What can possibly happen next?
Here are some thoughts on additional moments of television greatness from 2012.
Homeland – I had sliced Showtime from my cable menu a few years back, not only to save a few bucks, but because I had maxed out on Weeds, Nurse Jackie and Dexter. So I missed the initial hubbub over Homeland, that is until the TV Academy sent me the Emmy screener with the first four episodes, which I devoured in awe and anxiety in a single binge night, leaving me Jonesing for more. I finished off Season One from the DVD via Netflix. I think it will stand as a perfect series, embodied by superb actors and propelled by a superior narrative engine. Of course, I resubscribed to SHO in time to start Season Two, which, while not nearly as perfect, certainly had its moments, especially the episode in which Carrie interrogates Brodie in the CIA safe house.
By odd happenstance, I was chatting with a guy at a conference in mid-season two who had himself worked for the NSA. He hated Homeland, citing all sorts of ridiculous anomalies and factual flaws. I suspected all along that theirs was fake verisimilitude, but then, nobody ever claimed that this is based upon facts, unlike the creators of the Zero Dark Thirty movie, which covers some of the same material. The point for the audience is that Homeland delivers uncomfortable truth in fictional form. And drives you back each week to find out what happens next.
Click to read more ...